Civic Accountability · Nigeria

NGScorecard

Previously in Benue:
Term report
10
Total tracked
2
Kept
4
Partial / mixed
4
Broken
Kept
Partial / mixed
Broken
In progress
Security
End insecurity and protect farmers from herder violence
Broken
The promise
Campaigned on prioritising the security of lives and property to end the farmer-herder conflict that has displaced hundreds of thousands of Benue residents.
Assessment
Violence has continued and, by several measures, worsened: Amnesty International recorded more than 6,800 people killed by suspected armed groups in Benue between 2023 and mid-2025, and on 13-14 June 2025 gunmen killed an estimated 100-200 people and displaced roughly 3,000 in the Yelwata massacre in Guma LGA, prompting Human Rights Watch to call on the government to prioritise security in the state.
Humanitarian
Support and resettle internally displaced persons
Partial
The promise
Promised sustained support for the large population of Benue residents displaced by insurgent and herder violence.
Assessment
The state emergency management agency (BENSEMA) has run 14-15 IDP camps with monthly relief distributions supported by the government, UNHCR, and NEMA, and the administration launched a formal IDP Policy aimed at shifting from relief to durable resettlement, with 80 families returning to ancestral homes by November 2025 — but the state's IDP population remains large and the June 2025 Yelwata massacre itself displaced roughly 3,000 more people, showing the underlying displacement crisis outpacing resettlement efforts.
Governance
Ensure regular payment of civil service salaries
Kept
The promise
Promised, on assuming office, to prioritise civil service reform and ensure workers were paid regularly, addressing a legacy of salary delays.
Assessment
The administration has remained largely faithful to prompt monthly salary payments since Alia's 29 May 2023 inauguration, a consistent point of praise even from critics of the wider administration.
Governance
Clear pension and gratuity arrears within 100 days
Broken
The promise
Promised to clear accumulated arrears of pensions and gratuities owed to retired civil servants within the administration's first 100 days in office.
Assessment
The 100-day pledge was not met, and multiple retirees had to seek relief through the National Industrial Court, which repeatedly ruled the state's withholding of pensions unlawful and ordered payment of arrears. Alia issued a fresh pledge in late 2025 to clear all outstanding pensions and gratuities owed between 2023 and 2025 by the end of January 2026.
Economy
Industrialise the state through agriculture and revive Taraku Mills
Partial
The promise
Promised to build an agriculture-led economy and revive the multi-billion-naira Taraku Mills as a flagship industrial project.
Assessment
Reviving Taraku Mills has remained a stated administration priority through 2025-2026, alongside broader agricultural development goals, but comprehensive independently verified evidence of the mill's actual resumption of production was not identified for this entry.
Infrastructure
Urban renewal and rural infrastructure investment
Kept
The promise
Promised an infrastructure renewal programme covering both Makurdi's urban core and rural electrification across local government areas.
Assessment
The administration launched simultaneous construction of 16 township roads in Makurdi under its Strategic Development Plan, extended rural electrification to several local government areas, and by June 2026 had commissioned 10 major projects including an ICT Centre and a NITDA facility.
Economy
Launch a youth empowerment scheme to reduce unemployment
Partial
The promise
Promised targeted youth empowerment programmes to cut unemployment, particularly through agricultural subsidies.
Assessment
The administration launched the Benue State Youth Empowerment Scheme in 2024, providing agricultural subsidies aimed at reducing unemployment; comprehensive independently verified job-creation or beneficiary-outcome data was not identified for this entry.
Governance
Ensure transparent, accountable use of public funds
Broken
The promise
Implicit obligation, given the debt and financial disputes surrounding the handover from the Ortom administration, to run a more transparent and accountable government.
Assessment
The administration has faced repeated fund-mismanagement allegations, including a civil society petition alleging N66 billion was mismanaged within four months of taking office, a N345.3 billion fraud allegation from a 2023 gubernatorial rival, and a 2026 EFCC investigation into an alleged N4.6 billion diversion of local government funds involving the Bureau for Local Government and Chieftaincy Affairs' own principal officers.
Security
Fully enforce the 2017 anti-open grazing law
Broken
The promise
Implicit obligation to enforce Benue's existing Open Grazing Prohibition and Ranches Establishment Law of 2017, widely seen as central to preventing renewed farmer-herder violence.
Assessment
Critics and even the Benue State House of Assembly itself have said the anti-open grazing law exists largely on paper under the administration, urging Alia to ensure full implementation following renewed herdsmen attacks; the administration's response has centred on forming a new 5,000-then-10,000-strong Civil Protection Guard rather than demonstrating consistent direct enforcement of the grazing ban itself.
Economy
Reduce the state's debt burden and stabilise finances
Partial
The promise
Promised fiscal responsibility and a reduction of the heavy debt burden he said Benue inherited from the Ortom administration.
Assessment
The debt figure itself became a point of public dispute between Alia and Ortom, and rather than improving, the state's fiscal pressure appears to have intensified: Benue's quarterly debt-service cost rose from ₦1.99 billion in Q4 2024 to ₦21.40 billion in Q1 2025, placing it among states whose debt-service costs exceeded their internally generated revenue.